Chini, Carmichael, Rebello, Puntambekar: AAPT Summer 2009 (Poster)

Can Simulations Replace Hands-on Experiments in Mechanics Too?*

Jacquelyn J. Chini, Adrian Carmichael, N. Sanjay Rebello
Kansas State University, Manhattan, KS 66506; USA

Sadhana Puntambaker
University of Wisconsin, Madison, WI 53706; USA

It has previously been demonstrated [1] that an appropriately designed simulation can be more effective than analogous hands-on activities in the context of circuits. Circuits involve microscopic phenomenon, such as the movement of electrons, which can be modeled more clearly by a computer than real equipment. Will simulations be more effective than hands-on activities in other contexts, too? We investigated whether simulations could effectively replace hands-on experiments in a unit on inclined planes from the CoMPASS curriculum, which integrates hypertext concept maps with design-based activities [2]. Three sections of an introductory physics laboratory completed hands-on experiments, and two sections completed the same experiment in simulation. Students who used the simulations performed statistically significantly better on the post-test than students who completed the hands-on experiments.

[1] Finkelstein, N.D., et al., “When learning about the real world is better done virtually: A study of substituting computer simulations for laboratory equipment.” PRST-PER, 2005. 1: p. 010103.[2] Puntambekar, S., A. Stylianou, and R. Hübscher, “Improving navigation and learning in hypertext environments with navigable concept maps.” Human-Computer Interaction, 2003. 18: p. 395-428.

*This work is funded in part by the U.S. Department of Education, Institute of Education Sciences, Award # R305A080507.